Brynzanska O. Criminal liability for ecocide under international law

https://doi.org/10.33098/2078-6670.2023.16.28.48-56

Purpose. The purpose of the article is to characterize the constitutional right of citizens to entrepreneurship as economic freedom (functional-teleological characteristic), to reveal its essence and meaning.Methodology includes the general scientific dialectical method, as well as other methods of scientific knowledge: functional, system-structural, and comparative methods. Results:  It was concluded that there is no regulation of ecocide in international law as an international crime outside the context of an armed conflict, which excludes international legal responsibility for its commission, or a crime of  international nature (transnational crime), which is due to the limited establishment of criminal responsibility for ecocide in the national legislation of many states. It has been established that ecocide can potentially be recognized as an international crime stricto sensu if the adoption of relevant amendments to the Statute of the International Criminal Court will be, and as a crime of an international nature if the adoption of a multilateral international treaty as universal legal standard will be. It was determined that a separate political and legal instrument of influence on national legislation is the establishment of standards of responsibility for environmental criminal offenses, including ecocide, within the framework of membership in international organizations (Council of Europe) and economic and political unions (EU). It was established that until now the development of the concept of ecocide in international law as an act characterized by signs of “seriousness”, “long-term” and “wide-spread” damage to the natural environment is at the stage of development. Originality. The legal nature of ecocide in the context of its belonging to an international crime / a crime of an international character as concepts of international criminal law is studied. Practical significance. The results of the study can be used in educational, law-making and law-enforcement activities in the course of developing the state criminal law policy.

Key words: ecocide, environmental crime, international crime stricto sensu, transnational crime, wide-spread, long-term and severe damage, the natural environment.

References

1. Krupska, K. (2016). Ekologichni organizaciyi na mizhnarodnij areni [Environmental organizations in the international arena]. Yurydychna gazeta, 45 (543). Avaliable at: https://artius.ua/novini/statti/ekologichni-organizacii.html (in Ukranian)

2. Ruslan Strelets took part in the second meeting of the International Working Group on the Environmental Consequences of the War. Ministerstvo zakhystu dovkillya ta pryrodnykh resursiv Ukrayiny. Avaliable at: https://mepr.gov.ua/ruslan-strilets-vzyav-uchast-u-drugomu-zasidanni-mizhnarodnoyi-robochoyi-grupy-shhodo-ekologichnyh-naslidkiv-vijny/.(in Ukranian)

3. Baymuratov, M.O. (2002). Mizhnarodne pravo [International law]. Kharkiv: Odissey. (in Ukranian).

4. Zelinska, N. A. (2007). Ponyattya «mizhnarodnyy zlochyn» v istoryko-pravovomu rakursi [The concept of “international crime” in a historical and legal perspective]. Aktualni problemy derzhavy i prava: zbirnyk nauk. Prats, 32, 271-278. Avaliable at:  http://www.apdp.in.ua/v32/55.pdf (in Ukranian).

5. Arkhypov, O.M. (2002). Spivvidnoshennya ponyat «mizhnarodnyy zlochyn» ta «zlochyn mizhnarodnoho kharakteru» [ Correlation between the concepts of “international crime” and “crime of an international nature”]. Pravova derzhava, 4, 110-114 Avaliable at:  http://pd.onu.edu.ua/article/view/216389/216483 (in Ukranian)

6. Butkevych,V. H. (2004). Mizhnarodne pravo: osnovni haluzi [International law: main areas].  Kyiv: Lybid. (in Ukranian)

7. Zelyns’ka, N. A. (2006). Mizhnarodni zlochyny i mizhnarodna zlochynnist: monohrafiya [International crimes and international crime]. Odesa: Yurydychna literatura. (in Ukranian)

8. Zadorozhniy, O.V., Butkevych, V.H., Mytsyk, V. V. (2001). Konspekt lektsiy z osnov teoriyi mizhnarodnoho prava [Synopsis of lectures on the basics of the theory of international law]. Kyiv: Lybid. (in Ukranian)

9. Zelinska, N. A., Andreychenko, S. S., Dromina-Volok, N. V., Koval D.O. (2017). Teoriya ta praktyka mizhnarodnoho kryminalnoho prava [Theory and practice of international criminal law]. Odesa: «Feniks», 2017. (in Ukranian).

10. Hrynchak, V. A. (2015). Pravova pryroda mizhnarodnykh zlochyniv [Legal nature of international crimes]. Visnyk L’vivs’koho universytetu. Seriya: mizhnarodni vidnosyny, 37. Part. 2, 17–22 URL:  https://intrel.lnu.edu.ua/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/162-419-1-PB.pdf (in Ukranian).

11. Hrushko, M.V. (2018). Voyenni zlochyny yak mizhnarodni zlochyny jus cogens. [War crimes as international jus cogens crimes]. Aktualni problemy vitchyznyanoyi yurysprudentsiyi, 1, 241–244. Avaliable at:  http://apnl.dnu.in.ua/1_2018/58.pdf (in Ukranian).

12. UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (1982, October 12). Informatsiyno-analitychna systema po zakonodavstvu Ukrayiny «Konsultant». URL: http://consultant.parus.ua/?doc=00O5WDC64C (in Ukranian)

13. International Criminal Court.  Statement to the 20th Assembly of States Parties to the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court. December 2021. Avaliable at: https://asp.icc-cpi.int/sites/asp/files/asp_docs/ASP20/ASP20.GD.StopEcocide.07.12.pdf (in English)

14. Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court: international document dated 07.17.1998. Zakonodavstvo Ukrayiny Avaliable at: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/995_588#Text (in Ukranian)

15. Hemptinne de J. Ecocide: an Ambiguous Crime? Blog of the European Journal of International Law. Avaliable at: https://www.ejiltalk.org/ecocide-an-ambiguous-crime/(in English).

16. Kutsevych, M. P. (2007). Criminal liability for ecocide: international and national aspects: PhD diss. Kyiv. (in Ukranian)

17. Shutyak S. Crimes against animals during wartime. Avaliable at: https://justtalk.com.ua/post/zlochini-proti-tvarin-pid-chas-vijni (in Ukranian)

18. The State of Knowledge of Crimes that have Serious Impacts on the Environment. UN Environment. Avaliable at: https://wedocs.unep.org/bitstream/handle/20.500.11822/25713/knowledge_crime_envImpacts.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y (in English)

19. International Monsanto Tribunal. Avaliable at:  https://www.monsanto-tribunal.org/How (in English).

20. Convention on the Protection of the Environment through Criminal Law. Strasbourg. 04.11.1998. European Treaty Series №. 172. Avaliable at:  https://rm.coe.int/168007f3f4 (in English).

21. Mapping commitments in the field of environment and climate change: preparation for EU accession: analytical paper (2023). Resursno-analitychnyy tsentr «Suspil’stvo i dovkillya». (in Ukranian).

22. Apelblat, M. (2023). European Parliament agrees on the recognition of ecocide in EU legislation. The Brussels Times. Sunday, 2 April 2023. Avaliable at: https://www.brusselstimes.com/439238/european-parliament-agrees-on-the-recognition-of-ecocide-in-eu-legislation (in English).

23. Report on the proposal for a directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on the protection of the environment through criminal law and replacing Directive 2008/99/EC (COM(2021)0851 – C9-0466/2021 – 2021/0422(COD)). Committee on Legal Affairs.. Avaliable at: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/A-9-2023-0087_EN.pdf (in English).